|More evidence against sweet drinks||01/15/20|
|How to 'cure' diabetes||01/08/20|
|Diabetics: stay off medication longer with a Mediterranean Diet||12/18/19|
|Protect your liver with coffee||12/11/19|
|When questionable research still proves something||12/04/19|
|High blood pressure? Exercise!||11/20/19|
|The risks of cutting too many calories||11/13/19|
|Just 4 healthy lifestyle factors make a big difference||11/06/19|
|Sugar-sweetened beverage sales ban contributes to lower intake||10/30/19|
|Put down the media at meal times||10/23/19|
|Better research on the impact of smaller plates||10/16/19|
|The strongest evidence yet: plant-based diets prevent diabetes||10/09/19|
|Gain less weight by snacking on nuts||10/02/19|
|All Health and Nutrition Bites|
More evidence that breakfast may not be as important as previously thought
Researchers in Australia scoured the literature for randomized controlled trials that looked at the effect of eating breakfast on either overall body weight, the number of calories consumed that day, or both. They identified 13 trials that met their minimum quality criteria; 7 looked at the effects of eating breakfast on change in body weight, and 10 looked at the effects of eating breakfast on the number of calories consumed overall.
Lose More Weight with a Big Breakfast
I've said for years that breakfast really is the most important meal of the day. Skipping breakfast appears to reduce your metabolism while actually delaying fat burning and increasing fat deposition. Having a higher-fiber breakfast of quickbreads or cereal not only helps you remain satisfied for longer, you'll eat your other meals more regularly throughout the day.
How to suppress hunger
Vigorous exercise is known to reduce appetite, at least during and immediately after exercising, but what we don't know for sure is why. Researchers have looked at various hormones (known as "gut hormones") associated with appetite regulation and there does appear to be a difference in the effects of different types of exercise on these appetite-regulating hormones. But does that actually translate to an effect on appetite, and is it different for different types of exercise?
Get the latest health and diet news - along with what you can do about it - sent to your Inbox once a week. Get Dr. Gourmet's Health and Nutrition Bites sent to you via email. Sign up now!
If you're working on your weight, should you eat breakfast or not? We've seen in one small study that those who skipped breakfast ate fewer calories overall - even though they did eat a little bit more than usual at lunch and dinner.
Similarly, a review and meta-analysis found that those who skipped breakfast tended to lose more weight than those who did not skip breakfast, although the studies included in that meta-analysis also tended to be quite small.
On the other hand, those who consumed most of their daily calories at breakfast - as opposed to having their largest meal of the day at dinner time - lost more weight, even though those consuming their largest meal of the day at dinner time were consuming the same number of calories.
Today we have another small study that looks at skipping breakfast in conjunction with exercise. Researchers in Bath, UK (J Nutr, nxz018 https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxz018) recruited just 12 young men to participate in their trial who were between the ages of 20 and 26, were already physically active, were of clinically normal weight, and were taking no medications or had other conditions that might affect the outcomes of the study.
Each participant visited the lab on three separate occasions that were at least 7 but not more than 30 days apart. On all 3 occasions, each participant consumed the same evening meal before 8pm, then came to the lab at 8am local time after having nothing but water for the intervening 12 hours. In a random order, the participants were then subjected to 1 of 3 experimental conditions:
1. Control: The participants consumed a standardized breakfast of oatmeal and rested for 3 hours, with blood drawn and other tests done to measure muscle usage, calories burned, and other data.
2. Breakfast before Exercise: The participants consumed the same standardized breakfast of oatmeal, then after a rest of 2 hours the participant rode an indoor recumbent bicycle for 60 minutes at 50% of their (pre-defined) peak power output. The same tests were done at the same times as the Control group. One hour after exercise these participants were fed a pre-determined lunch and instructed to eat all they wanted, with the amount they consumed measured and recorded.
3. No Breakfast: The participants did not receive breakfast, but after the 2-hour rest period (plus the time they would have spent eating breakfast), the participants also rode the recumbent bike for an hour. These participants were also given the same lunch one hour after exercising, with the amount they consumed weighed and measured.
All three group's participants were provided with pre-weighed foods for them to consume as they chose over the course of the rest of the test day. Leftovers were returned to the lab the following morning for weighing.
The authors of the study were interested in whether consuming breakfast made a difference in the number of calories burned over the course of the 24-hour test period, as well as whether having breakfast before exercising led to greater or lesser consumption at lunch. Presumably those who exercised without having breakfast would eat more at lunch than those who had breakfast before exercising. Right?
It appears not. Somewhat surprisingly, the authors found that the participants who exercised did not seem to consume more at lunch when they didn't have breakfast: the difference in consumption between those exercisers who had breakfast and those who didn't was just a difference of about 160 calories, with those skipping breakfast eating the larger amount.
That said, those 160 extra calories at lunch weren't nearly the amount consumed at the lab's breakfast, which contained about 430 calories. That's a difference of 270 calories, or almost enough of a daily reduction in calories to cause a weekly weight loss of almost a pound - and that's not counting the calories burned while exercising.
This is a small study done in young, active men, so it's tough to say that this will work for everyone. However, this does suggest that if you exercise in the morning, instead of eating breakfast, it may help you to lose weight because you're less hungry at lunch than you would be if you skipped breakfast and did not exercise. This may be, as we have seen in other studies, because exercise helps reduce hunger.
First posted: April 24, 2019