|Conventional wisdom may be right about acne||07/01/20|
|Should you salt your pasta water?||06/24/20|
|Should you go vegetarian or vegan for your heart?||06/17/20|
|Three ways drinking soda is bad for your heart||06/10/20|
|Should you stop drinking coffee as you get older?||06/03/20|
|More evidence that fruits and vegetables are good for your heart||05/20/20|
|Tomato juice may improve blood pressures||05/13/20|
|Putting paid to the coconut oil myth once and for all||05/06/20|
|Milk and ovarian cancer||04/29/20|
|Put the egg myth to rest||04/15/20|
|Protect your eyes with legumes||04/08/20|
|Good for you: less exercise than you might think||04/01/20|
|All Health and Nutrition Bites|
Will drinking more water counteract the high sodium in some foods?
I attended a health seminar where you mentioned how important it is to reduce the sodium and not have more than the daily recommended value. You gave a few examples of the amount of sodium in some fast food and chain restaurant meals and how the daily maximum could quickly be reached. If I do have these items will drinking extra water counteract the increase in sodium?
Sodium and Stroke
The United States Department of Agriculture recommends that Americans limit their sodium intake to less than 2400 milligrams per day. The American Heart Association, however, recommends a limit of 1500 milligrams per day. We know that high levels of sodium in the diet are linked to high blood pressure and thus to the risk of stroke, but until recently many studies have not tried to link sodium and stroke more directly.
Finding a direct link from sodium to heart disease
I like to tell my medical students that "medicine is not math." Remember that Transitive Property of Equality you might have learned about in Algebra? Where if A = B and B = C, then A always equals C?
Get the latest health and diet news - along with what you can do about it - sent to your Inbox once a week. Get Dr. Gourmet's Health and Nutrition Bites sent to you via email. Sign up now!
When scientific studies are reported on in the media they can appear far more conclusive than they really are. For example, many clinical studies in humans have shown a link between high sodium (salt) intake and high blood pressure. Based on that evidence, the American Heart Association has recommended a maximum daily intake of less than 2300 milligrams of sodium. Yet there are still those scientists who argue, based on other studies, that improving overall dietary quality, including high intake of fruits and vegetables and adequate intake of minerals like potassium and calcium, is just as important as salt intake to reducing high blood pressure in humans.
These conflicting interpretations of scientific studies in humans are perfectly reasonable when you realize that the effects of changes in the human diet are affected by multiple variables, including age, gender, body weight, smoking status, and more. It's simply not feasible to control all other variables so that the effects of salt intake can be assessed as accurately as possible.
That said, it is possible to control all other dietary variables - if you don't use humans.
An international group of scientists studied the effects of varying levels of salt intake in chimpanzees, our closest genetic neighbors (Circulation. 2007;116(14):1563-1568). Unlike studies of humans, the scientists were able to control the monkeys' dietary intake with great accuracy, as their diet consisted solely of vegetables and fruits supplemented with dietary "biscuits." These biscuits provided the chimps with potassium, calcium, and salt in specific amounts, so the biscuits could be manipulated to provide varying levels of sodium in the monkeys' diet. Obviously humans would find it difficult to tolerate such a restricted diet - nor could they participate in such a study for the term of this study, which was over two years in length.
The results are striking: Increases in sodium intake were clearly linked to increases in blood pressure. Similarly, decreases in blood pressure were seen along with dietary decreases in salt intake. The amount of salt in the monkeys' diet, unlike other, previous studies, was similar to the amount of salt in that of humans and represented the high sodium intake of a typical Western diet (as much as 6-8 grams of sodium per day) versus that of current recommendations (about 2 grams per day).
It's hard to draw conclusions from animal studies that clearly apply to humans, so you won't see me talking about them all that much. However, this one is pretty compelling, as it removes a lot of the complicating variables and controls the participants' salt intake very accurately and for an extended period of time. No study is absolutely conclusive, but this one adds a hefty weight to the sodium-intake side of the blood pressure debate.
First posted: October 3, 2007