MENU
 

More Health and Nutrition Bites

High-glycemic-index diets linked to risk of Alzheimer's Disease 12/06/17
Pro-inflammatory diets lead to weight gain 11/29/17
"Meal" vs. "snack": the name matters 11/22/17
Beans reduce insulin response 11/15/17
Warfarin may help prevent cancer 11/08/17
Most satisfying: dark or milk chocolate? 11/01/17
Portion size more important than turning off the TV 10/25/17
The importance of breakfast (it's not what you think) 10/18/17
Diet quality matters 10/11/17
Coffee and your heart 10/04/17
Get your exercise 09/27/17
Mushrooms vs. Meat 09/20/17
Good news for GERD sufferers 09/14/17
Reseal the bag 09/06/17
All Health and Nutrition Bites

Related

Eat your antioxidants
People often rely on vitamin supplements to make up for their poor diets. This is especially true now that we know that some vitamins, such as antioxidants (vitamins E, C, or beta-carotene) or B vitamins, have been shown in the lab to help prevent such conditions as cancer, heart disease, and high cholesterol. But are the supplements actually having the same impact as a diet that contains more vitamins through diet alone?

What are Antioxidants?
When the cells in your body use oxygen, the interaction with other molecules results in their oxidation. The by-product of that oxidation is free radicals -- molecules or atoms that lose one or more electrons. Free radicals are unstable, and in a sense, are looking to replace or give up their unbalanced number of electrons. In scavenging for electrons, they cause damage to cells in the body. That is known as "oxidative stress" and this cellular damage contributes to disease.

Cooking Methods and Nutrients
A couple of weeks ago I responded to an Ask Dr. Gourmet question about microwaving. The letter writer was concerned because she'd been told that microwaving fresh vegetables "destroyed up to 95% of the nutrients." I responded by saying, essentially, that there is some bad news/good news here: the bad news is that all cooking processes affect the amount of nutrients in foods. The good news, however, is that microwaving actually affects nutrient loss the least.


 

Health & Nutrition Bites

Antioxidant Supplements May Be Bad For You



We know that a diet high in fruits and vegetables can help you avoid heart disease as well several different types of cancers, including oral cancer, skin cancer, prostate cancer and colon or rectal cancers (News Bite 12/12/07). We also know that a diet rich in fruits and vegetables can help you avoid Alzheimer's Disease (News Bite 9/05/06). But what is it, exactly, that's so protective? Some studies suggest that the protective substances are the antioxidant vitamins, which include vitamins A, C, and E along with beta-carotene and selenium.

If that's true, then it would be reasonable to believe that antioxidant supplements in pill form would help protect you from illness or even make you better, right? After all, we know that the omega-3 fatty acids in fish oil supplements seem to work just as well as eating fish (News Bite 4/30/08). We in medicine know, however, that it's always wise to check our assumptions and look for evidence - that's why we call it "evidence-based medicine."

Recently the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews published a review article assessing the effects of antioxidant supplements (2008;2. Art. No. CD007176). A review article pools the data from multiple, similar studies to yield stronger, more definitive results than the smaller studies can on their own. In this article, the reviewers included 67 studies which involved over 232,000 people. Forty-six of the studies looked at the effect of antioxidant supplements on those who already had diseases such as cancer or heart disease, while twenty-one evaluated the supplements' effects on those who were healthy. For all of the studies, the reviewers calculated whether the subjects' risk of death were higher, lower, or the same when they were taking antioxidants.

Let's go back to our reasonable belief about antioxidants in pill form. Reasonable? Yes. True? Unfortunately, no. The results of the review show that supplements of beta-carotene, vitamin A, and vitamin E, whether given in combination or by themselves, actually increased the subjects' risk of death, regardless of whether the study was on those who were already ill or on those who were healthy. The results for vitamin C and selenium, however, were inconclusive.

What this means for you

It's clear that there's no substitute for good food. Indeed, this study shows that antioxidant supplements can actually harm you. Best to have a well-balanced diet with plenty of fruits and vegetables rather than trying to get your health from pills.

First posted: January 21, 2009